Same Mistake, Different Day

You correct a team member’s mistake, offer constructive feedback, and assume the issue is resolved. But then, like déjà vu, it happens again. And again. At first, you might dismiss it as a simple oversight. Maybe they were having an off day or missed a small detail. But as the same mistake keeps repeating – three, four, even five times – frustration sets in.

You start wondering:

• Are they not paying attention?
• Do they not care?
• Are they overwhelmed?
• Or (hardest of all to admit) is there something off in how you’re managing or communicating?

So, what’s really going on, and how do you fix it without creating tension or disengagement?

1. Step Back and Identify the Root Cause

Before you correct the mistake again, dig deeper into why it’s happening. Here are some specific steps to diagnose the issue:

• Is it a skills gap? They may need additional training or mentorship.
• Is it a motivation issue? Personal issues, burnout, or disengagement could be affecting performance.
• Are expectations unclear? Ensure they understand their role, goals, and responsibilities.
• Is there a cultural or team dynamic problem? Conflicts with colleagues or a poor team fit can impact performance.
• Are they overwhelmed? A high workload or unclear priorities can lead to mistakes and stress.

Having a direct and open conversation with the employee can help uncover what’s really going on.

📝Note: Often, the cause isn’t just one thing, it’s a combination of factors. An employee might be making mistakes because they’re overwhelmed, but the stress is amplified by unclear expectations or a lack of proper training. Or they could be disengaged due to personal challenges while also struggling with a skills gap that hasn’t been addressed. These issues don’t always exist in isolation, and addressing just one may not fully solve the problem.

2. Make Your Feedback Stick

Repeating the same feedback clearly isn’t working, so it’s time to reinforce it differently. This means you’ll have to cut out all the fluff from the feedback and try something like this:

• Have them explain it back to you. After correcting the mistake, say, “Can you walk me through how you’ll approach this next time?” If they struggle, they haven’t internalized it.
• Use real examples. Instead of saying, “You need to check your work,” show them a specific mistake and say, “Here’s where it went wrong – how would you catch this next time?”
• Follow up with reminders. If they often forget a key step, set a recurring reminder, create a checklist, or integrate a review process into their workflow.

3. Create a Consequence-Based System

Sometimes, the missing piece is accountability. Set up a clear structure so they own their performance:

• Tie mistakes to impact. Instead of just saying “This needs to be fixed,” explain, “When this data is incorrect, it delays the entire project by a day.”
• Assign responsibility for fixing mistakes. If they make an error, don’t just correct it for them: make them go back, analyze what went wrong, and fix it themselves.

4. Adjust the Role or Task If Necessary

If a team member consistently struggles with the same type of task despite coaching, it might be a sign of a skill mismatch. Consider:

• Reassigning responsibilities. If they thrive in creative work but struggle with detail-heavy tasks, shift their focus accordingly.
• Providing specialized training. If they lack a fundamental skill, invest in training instead of expecting improvement through repetition.
• Setting a trial period for improvement. If mistakes persist, establish a 30-day improvement plan with specific goals and check-ins.

5. Know When It’s a Performance Issue

If you’ve provided feedback, training, accountability, and adjustments, and mistakes still persist, it may be a deeper performance issue.

In this case:

• Have a direct performance conversation. Make it clear that improvement is expected, and outline consequences if mistakes continue.
• Document the issue. Keep track of repeated errors, previous coaching efforts, and the employee’s responses.
• Involve HR if necessary. If the mistakes are affecting team efficiency or business outcomes, it may be time for formal performance management steps.

6. When to Cut Ties

If repeated efforts don’t yield improvement, it may be time to consider a transition. Here are key indicators that an employee may not be the right fit:

• Lack of effort or resistance to feedback. If they aren’t trying to improve, no amount of coaching will work.
• Continuous mistakes that impact the team. If their errors create inefficiencies or extra work for others, it’s a problem.
• Negative attitude or behavioral issues. Poor teamwork, lack of accountability, or a toxic attitude can harm team morale.
• No improvement despite clear expectations. If they consistently fail to meet agreed-upon goals, the role may not be the right fit.

When performance isn’t improving, keeping them on board can be more damaging than letting them go.

Wrapping Up

In the end, repeating mistakes often behave like chronic pain. At first, it’s something you can manage, maybe even ignore, hoping it will go away on its own. But as time goes on, the frustration builds, and the problem becomes harder to dismiss. Just as chronic pain signals a deeper issue in the body, persistent mistakes often point to an underlying cause that isn’t being addressed. You might patch over the symptoms, but without understanding what’s truly driving the errors, the cycle continues, draining energy and productivity.

If you found this article valuable:

• Follow me for more articles on remote team processes, tips and hiring ⇢ Milos Eric
• Check out OysterLink, a new platform for restaurant and hospitality careers. Find jobs, career tips, and insights. Learn and grow with us ⇢ https://oysterlink.com/