FTFA
I'm concerned about the state of pilot training that has developed over the past decade. Ever since we have introduced more and more computers into the cockpit it seems that we are training our pilots to be monitors of computer systems rather than flyers.
Back in the pre-politically correct age when I began to fly my instructor, Scotty, would give me a failure of an airplane system and then admonish me on how to fix it as I struggled to fly the airplane and fix the problem. Goddammit Gordon. You look like a monkey f------ a football. Fly the f------ airplane, then fix the problem. FTFA stuck in my mind for my entire career. I have cleaned up the phrase a bit as I have passed it on to a couple of generations of pilots. Now I can comfortably say, "Fly the friggin airplane" and not be prosecuted but I hope the memory of FTFA stays in their minds.
Another aviation executive and I have discussed this issue many times. Him from the stance of running a P&L business and me from a professional pilot's viewpoint. I argued that the training departments should add an additional hour to the recurrent simulator sessions. Use it to keep the pilots familiar with the technique of turning off all of the magical stuff in the cockpit and flying on needle, ball and airspeed. His argument was that he was striving for the most efficient use of the crews. I think the accidents on the 737 Max have skewed the debate more in my favor. Issues that now cause accidents can be buried deep within millions of lines of code or imbedded in newly developed hardware. We've come a long way from the causal factor always being "Pilot Error".
We must have one button on each control wheel, or device, that turns off all of the auto flight capabilities of the airplane and lets the pilots, who should be well trained, hand fly the airplane and bring home the tin.
Patrick you do not pull your punches and you are quite correct to do so. The basic proposition that there might be something that happens to an aircraft that the "qualified" pilot is not able to deal with or perhaps understand is truly unacceptable and undermines trust in a system that was developed over 50 years. We all have huge respect for the guys that moved from the DC3 era to the B747 but unfortunately it appears their views might have been ignored or over-ridden by systems engineers.
Great article Pat! We pilots of a bygone era were drilled into flying raw data and it stood us in good stead! The two accidents of Ethiopian Airways and Indonesian Air in addition to the Air Asia and Air France tragedies only highlights the imperative need of companies to insist on regular and exhaustive refresher training on raw data flying!!
Great job as always Captain - hope you are doing great!