Post No: 022 Why Field Injection Is a Bad Idea in Spring Boot? Field injection (using @Autowired directly on variables) looks clean and easy, but it hides important details. When dependencies are injected into fields, you can’t easily see what a class really needs to work. This makes the code harder to understand, harder to test, and easier to break. In unit tests, you often have to use reflection or Spring itself just to create the object, which defeats the purpose of simple testing. Constructor injection is a better choice because it makes dependencies clear and mandatory. If something is required, it must be passed in the constructor, so the object is always created in a valid state. It also makes your code easier to test, more readable, and safer for future changes. Clean code is not about writing less code—it’s about writing code that’s easy to maintain. #SpringBoot #Java #CleanCode #BackendDevelopment #SoftwareEngineering
Field injection also hide circular injection issues
Agree
True, Constructor injection should be the default. However, in cases of unavoidable cyclic dependencies or lifecycle-dependent wiring, method or setter injection is best possible alternative to be brought into the picture. Right code is right decision in right place and time. It eventually leads to easy maintenance.